GoodFood Bit(e)s GoodFood project deals with Food Safety and Quality and, although multidisciplinary, originates as an Information Society Technology (IST) initiative, which is an interesting and complementary viewpoint when talking about food. From this interesting side road, important contributions can be made, but given that the Agrofood arena is extremely large, it is easy for an IST specialist to miss a general view. These GoodFood Food ‘Bites' are intended to offer to any interested people -non specialists on Food Technology- elements to build up a little bit of knowledge. Apart from statements extracted from textbooks and our own experience, some of the information contained in these ‘bites' has been elaborated from (and in some cases merely transcripted from) the following very interesting reports that deserve their due merit, and can be further explored by any interested reader : (2002) Report from Tekes (National Technology Agency of Finland ) ‘Technological Trends and Needs in Food Diagnostics' (2002) Expert Report from the Institute of Food Technologist ‘Emerging Microbiological Food Safety Issues. Implications for control in the 21st century' (2004) Report from the French Senate ‘Les nouveaux apports de la science et de la technologie à la qualité et à la sûrete des aliments'
GoodFood logos explanations Apart from nice and witty pictures logos should convey some meaning. In Goodfood material a couple of logos can be seen. Here follow the rationales that are behind them.
This first logo was designed by SSSA. The central point is a well known masterpiece of Giuseppe Arcimboldo (1530-1593). Our intention was to embody in this image the popular saying ‘we are what we eat'. This statement of popular wit, which almost has a version in every idiom, is in fact of German origin: Man ist, was man isst (probably one of the few examples of musicality of the German language that a non-German can appreciate). With this sentence and this image we want to make evident how important for our wellbeing is not only food but its proper control in terms of safety and quality. In our logo the Arcimboldo painting is divided in sectors to exemplify that when we talk about food we must consider the whole food chain , which consists of different steps in which there is room for improvements regarding food safety and quality.
The second logo was designed by CSIC-CNM In this case the logo intention was to show that food monitoring is the technological objective of GoodFood. In this way, food is the main target of all the ambient intelligence based in Microsystems that will be developed in the project. Our aim is to provide tools that could be deployed in order to provide closer, more automatic and more frequent control of food with the aim of increasing the safety and quality of the food chain. In a way, both logos are a graphical form of GoodFood logo: bringing the lab to the foodstuff… from the land to the market. Agrofood: one of the earliest innovation arenas. Possibly we cannot allow us renouncing to innovate in such a traditional arena as agrofood. Probably we can not even avoid it. But, in any case, the word traditional should not misguide us: innovation in the agrofood is not a recent matter. Unlike other fields, the onset of its evolution has not been the information revolution, nor the previous industrial revolution by that matter. Agrofood is so linked to our survival that it hardly could have waited so long. Producing enough food to satisfy the needs of a growing human population means obtaining raw material in sufficient quantity and quality. The search for sufficient resources has resulted in countless innovations over the last ten thousand years, from the appearance of agriculture to present times. Not to mention the social leaps, the organizative evolution enabled by agrofood procedures. This social transformation took us from hunter-gatherers to herdsmen and then to sendentary settlers allowing to divert some precious time and energy from mere survival to civilization. Here follow a few examples of those early innovations in the agrofood field. In the case of agriculture, for instance, irrigation began 7000 years ago and olives were first converted into oil at the same time in Egypt. Crop rotation was introduced in the 17th century, and the use of chemical fertilizers, the mechanisation of labours and first phytosanitary treatments date back to the 19th century. In livestock farming, animal selection started 6000 years ago and stabling dates back to the 14th century. In the 19th century intensive livestock farming took form and the first genetic improvements were introduced by directed crossbreeding. Intensive fishing also dates back to the 14th century. The overfishing of the 20th century has driven fish industry into aquaculture, which again is not a rather new discipline. Mollusc aquaculture was know in the 1st century: Romans harvested mussels and Japanese oysters. Even 4000 years ago fresh water carps were cultivated in China. Food quickly goes bad due to the action of microorganisms (bacteria & fungi), the catalytic action of enzymes and it also looses characteristics by physical reactions (as when bread hardens). Our ancestors did not know the ultimate reasons but they knew that food spoiled, that raw materials riped according to their own biological rythm and that it was not enough to store them to have them available anytime, so there was always a need of promoting their preservation for enabling its consumption anytime, anywhere. The benefits of drying food were long known. Salting and smoking were traditional ways of drying. Salting herring and cod (allowing a year around conservation) managed to feed the growing European population in the 13th and 14th century. Modern lyophylisation (also known as freeze drying) was perfected in 19th century and incorporated in the food industry in 1958, but long ago the Incas took profit of the Andean Altiplano weather conditions (low atmospheric pressure and harsh cold at night) to preserve food in such way (incidentally, the same process that helped preserving the Inca mummies). Freezing by itself has been used since ancient times but its modern use began for preserving food during transport (fish, England XVIII). 1929 marks the onset of domestic freezing that brought the production of frozen food in household portions, one of those examples of mutual impact of agrofood and social evolution. But talking of food preservation we should not forget heat. 10,000 years ago cooking food in recipients was a generalized practice. Heat makes food go bad more slowly (eliminates microorganisms), but also give food a different taste and facilitates digestion on many cases (like in the case of pulses). The employ of heat has known different forms, from the traditional smoking to the new electromagnetic heating or irradiation, not forgetting the bain marie, the 1679 pressure cooker (that lead to the autoclave) and pasteurisation (1860). Heat is also intimately linked to canning as a preservation process. Appert led the way sterilising sealed jars in 1809 as a result of a 1795 prize set by Napoleon to whom could find a means of preserving food for army and navy use (another agrofood innovation led by a mobility ‘social’ demand). In 1810 Peter Durand of England patented the use of tin-coated iron cans instead of bottles. More about historic canning and bottling: ancient cultures stored cereals in silos in the ground and learnt to consume the oxigen with a fire before sealing them. Greek sealed amphoras as well for transport and storing. Glass bottles could be seen scarcely in Rome, but they were not more widely spread till XVII. On the other hand, the wooden barrels with metal hoops, which are of celtic origin, were quite common in Rome 2000 years ago. Another traditional way of food preservation was fermentation. In this case it is the action of microorganisms what creates suitable conditions for preserving food, whilst also modifying the product giving it new characteristics, taste and aroma. Fermentation can take different forms: dairy, alcoholic, malolactic, acetic, citric acid. Different fermentation products are dairy products, sausages & ham, vinegar... and of course which ancient civilization has not brewed its own wine, beer, cider, alcohol fermented milk or corn...? Food preservation Since most foods either carry or eventually acquire bacteria, molds, or yeasts, microorganisms are the major causes of food spoilage. Other factors leading to deterioration or spoilage are the natural enzymes present in some foods and various chemical reactions, particularly oxidation. Among the major processes for food preservation are cooling or freezing, dehydration, canning, smoking, salting, candying, and the addition of chemical preservatives and inhibitors. Often several principles are applied in combination, such as freeze drying. Techniques for preserving food from natural deterioration, following harvest or slaughter, date to prehistoric times. Among the oldest methods of preservation are drying, refrigeration, and fermentation. (The practice of preserving food can be traced to prehistory, when fruits and vegetables were dried, cereal grains were parched, and fish and game were salted and dried. These age-old methods developed very slowly and were purely empirical--fermentation, drying, smoking, and curing with salt being the principal techniques.) Modern methods include canning, pasteurization, freezing, irradiation, and the addition of chemicals. The modern objective of food preservation includes concern for food quality, for economy, and, especially, for convenience in addition to the prevention of spoilage. Colour or appearance, flavour, texture or consistency, and nutritive value are the major quality factors. Bacteria and fungi (yeasts and molds) are the principal types of microorganisms that cause food spoilage and food-borne illnesses. Foods may be contaminated by microorganisms at any time during harvest, storage, processing, distribution, handling, or preparation. The primary sources of microbial contamination are soil, air, animal feed, animal hides and intestines, plant surfaces, sewage, and food processing machinery or utensils. Bacteria are unicellular organisms that have a simple internal structure compared with the cells of other organisms. Bacterial populaton grows as a result of the division of one bacterial cell into two identical bacterial cells, a process called binary fission. The factors that influence the growth of bacteria include nutrient availability, moisture, pH, oxygen levels, and the presence or absence of inhibiting substances (e.g., antibiotics). The nutritional requirements of most bacteria are chemical elements such as carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur, magnesium, potassium, sodium, calcium, and iron. The bacteria obtain these elements by utilizing gases in the atmosphere and by metabolizing certain food constituents such as carbohydrates and proteins.Temperature and pH play a significant role in controlling the growth rates of bacteria. Bacteria may be classified into three groups based on their temperature requirement for optimal growth: thermophiles (55°-75° C), mesophiles (20° -45° C), orpsychrotrophs (10°-20° C). In addition, most bacteria grow best in a neutral environment (pH equal to 7). Bacteria also require a certain amount of available water for their growth. Growth may be controlled by lowering the water activity--either by adding solutes such as sugar, glycerol, and salt or by removing water through dehydration. The two types of fungi that are important in food spoilage are yeasts and molds. Molds are multicellular fungi that reproduce by the formation of spores (single cells that can grow into a mature fungus). Spores are formed in large numbers and are easily dispersed through the air. Once these spores land on a food substrate, they can grow and reproduce if conditions are favourable. Yeasts are unicellular fungi that are much larger than bacterial cells. They reproduce by cell division (binary fission) or budding. The conditions affecting the growth of fungi are similar to those affecting bacteria. Both yeasts and molds are able to grow in an acidic environment (pH less than 7). The pH range for yeast growth is 3.5 to 4.5 and for molds is 3.5 to 8.0. The low pH of fruits is generally unfavourable for the growth of bacteria, but yeasts and molds can grow and cause spoilage in fruits. The amount of available water in a food product is also critical for the growth of fungi. Enzymes are large protein molecules that act as biological catalysts, accelerating chemical reactions without being consumed to any appreciable extent themselves. The activity of enzymes is specific for a certain set of chemical substrates, and it is dependent on both pH and temperature. The living tissues of plants and animals maintain a balance of enzymatic activity. This balance is disrupted upon harvest or slaughter. In some cases, enzymes that play a useful role in living tissues may catalyze spoilage reactions following harvest or slaughter. The chemical reactions catalyzed by the enzymes result in the degradation of food quality, such as the development of off-flavours, the deterioration of texture, and the loss of nutrients Although microorganisms are usually thought of as causing spoilage, they are capable under certain conditions of producing desirable effects such as certain types of fermentation. An important food preservation method combines salting to control microorganisms selectively and fermentation to stabilize the treated tissues. LOW-TEMPERATURE PRESERVATION Storage at low temperatures prolongs the shelf life of many foods. In general, low temperatures reduce the growth rates of microorganisms and slow many of the physical and chemical reactions that occur in foods. Rrefrigeration is used to store foodstuffs at low temperatures, thus inhibiting the destructive action of bacteria, yeast, and mold. Many perishable products can be frozen, permitting them to be kept for months and even years with little loss in nutrition or flavour or change in appearance. Before mechanical refrigeration systems were introduced, ancient peoples, including the Greeks and Romans, cooled their food with ice transported from the mountains. Wealthy families made use of snow cellars, pits that were dug into the ground and insulated with wood and straw, to store the ice. In this manner, packed snow and ice could be preserved for months. Stored ice was the principal means of refrigeration until the beginning of the 20th century, and it is still used in some areas. In India and Egypt evaporative cooling was employed. If a liquid is rapidly vaporized, it expands quickly. The rising molecules of vapour abruptly increase their kinetic energy. Much of this increase is drawn from the immediate surroundings of the vapour, which are therefore cooled. Cooling caused by the rapid expansion of gases is the primary means of refrigeration today. The technique of evaporative cooling has been known for centuries, but the fundamental methods of mechanical refrigeration were only discovered in the middle of the 19th century. Freezing It is a method of preserving food by lowering the temperature below 0ºC to inhibit microorganism growth. The method has been used for centuries in cold regions, and a patent was issued in Britain as early as 1842 for freezing food by immersion in an ice and salt brine. It was not, however, until the advent of mechanical refrigeration that the process became widely applicable commercially. In 1880 a cargo of meat shipped from Australia to Britain under refrigeration accidentally froze, with such good results that the process was at once adopted for long-distance shipments and other storage. CONTROLLING WATER ACTIVITY Foods containing high concentrations of water are generally more susceptible to deterioration by microbial contamination and enzymatic activity. The water content of foods can be controlled by removing water through dehydration or by adding solutes to the food. In both cases the concentration of solutes in the food increases and the concentration of water decreases. Foods with substantial acidity, when concentrated to 65 percent or more soluble solids, may be preserved by mild heat treatments. High acid content is not a requirement for preserving foods concentrated to over 70 percent solids. Jellies and other fruit preserves are prepared from fruit by adding sugar and concentrating by evaporation to a point where microbial spoilage cannot occur. The prepared product can be stored without hermetic sealing, although such protection is useful to control mold growth, moisture loss, and oxidation. Drying The principal methods of drying, or dehydrating, food are by forced-air drying, vacuum drying, or vacuum freeze-drying. Each of these methods involves adding heat to aid in the removal of water Curing Curing reduces water activity through the addition of chemicals, such as salt, sugars, or acids. There are two main types of salt-curing used in the fish industry: dry salting and pickle-curing. In dry salting the butchered fish is split along the backbone and buried in salt (called a wet stack). Brine is drained off until the water content of the flesh is reduced to approximately 50 percent (the typical water content of fresh fish is 75 to 80 percent) and the salt content approaches 25 percent. In pickle-curing, fish are preserved in airtight barrels in a strong pickle solution formed by the dissolving of salt in the body fluids. This curing method is used for fatty fish such as herring Smoking Traditionally, smoking was a combination of drying and adding chemicals from the smoke to the fish, thus preserving and adding flavour to the final product. However, much of the fish smoked today is exposed to smoke just long enough to provide the desired flavour with little, if any, drying. These products, called kippered fish, have short shelf lives, even under refrigeration, since the water activity remains high enough for spoilage organisms to grow. THERMAL PROCESSING Thermal processing is defined as the combination of temperature and time required to eliminate a desired number of microorganisms from a food product. Canning Nicolas Appert, a Parisian confectioner by trade, is credited with establishing the heat processing of foods as an industry. In 1810 he received official recognition for his process of enclosing food in bottles, corking the bottles, and placing the bottles in boiling water for various periods of time. In the same year Peter Durand received a British patent for the use of containers made of glass, pottery, tin, or other metals for the heat preservation of foods. In 1822 Ezra Daggett and Thomas Kensett announced the availability of preserved foods in tin cans in the United States. Tin-coated steel containers, made from 98.5 percent sheet steel with a thin coating of tin, soon became common. The establishment of the canning process on a more scientific basis did not occur until 1896, when the microorganism Clostridium botulinum, with its lethal toxin causing botulism, was discovered by Émile van Ermengem. The thermal processes of canning are generally designed to destroy this microorganism. Sterilization requires heating to temperatures greater than 100° C. However, C. botulinum is not viable in acidic foods that have a pH less than 4.6. These foods can be adequately processed by immersion in water at temperatures just below 100° C. Pasteurization Pasteurization is the application of heat to a food product in order to destroy pathogenic (disease-producing) microorganisms, to inactivate spoilage-causing enzymes, and to reduce or destroy spoilage microorganisms. The relatively mild heat treatment used in the pasteurization process causes minimal changes in the sensory and nutritional characteristics of foods compared to the severe heat treatments used in the sterilization process. The temperature and time requirements of the pasteurization process are influenced by the pH of the food. When the pH is below 4.5, spoilage microorganisms and enzymes are the main targets of pasteurization.The typical processing conditions for the pasteurization of fruit juices include heating to 77° C and holding for 1 minute, followed by rapid cooling to 7° C. In addition to inactivating enzymes, these conditions destroy any yeasts or molds that may lead to spoilage. When the pH of a food is greater than 4.5, the heat treatment must be severe enough to destroy pathogenic bacteria. The typical heat treatment used for pasteurizing milk is 72° C for 15 seconds, followed by rapid cooling to 7° C. Other equivalent heat treatments include heating to 63° C (145° F) for 30 minutes, 90° C (194° F) for 0.5 second, and 94° C (201° F) for 0.1 second. The high-temperature-short-time (HTST) treatments cause less damage to the nutrient composition and sensory characteristics of foods and therefore are preferred over the low-temperature-long-time (LTLT) treatments. Since the heat treatment of pasteurization is not severe enough to render a product sterile, additional methods such as refrigeration, fermentation, or the addition of chemicals are often used to control microbial growth and to extend the shelf life of a product. Foodborne illness There are more than 200 known diseases caused by pathogens, their toxins, or other substances transmitted through food. A cause has not been identified for more than half of all those recognized foodborne diseases. Also, sometimes new information allows to link illness to activities or foods that had previously been unrecognized as a source of foodborne illness. Some pathogens cause a gret number of illnesses but the fatality is very small. Others cause few illnesses, but many of those illnesses are fatal. Once eaten a contaminated food, the onset of the symptons can vary from less than one hour to several weeks. Again, the length of illness varies greatly. Some illnesses resolve within a day or two, but others linger for weeks, may cause chronic disease, and even death. Foodborne illness can be reduced to three factors: the pathogen, the host, and the environment in which they interact. The host age, gender, place of residence, ethnicity, unerlying health affects the individual’s susceptibility to infection and illness. Knowledge, attitudes and practices related to health and diet affect exposure to pathogens. Susceptibility to infectious disease is the inability of the host’s body to prevent or overcome invasion by pathogenic microorganisms. Susceptibility is increased by conditions that alter the host defenses and suppress the function of the immune system. Many factors cause changes in the immune system function, such as age, health conditions (e.g. AIDS, cancer), pregnancy, nutritional satus, and antacid/ medication use. An important contributor to microbial pathogenicity and human illness is the changing human population and its behavior. The portion of the population that is elderly continues to grow, and large numbers of individuals have conditions necessitating the use of immnuosuppressive drugs or drug combinations with unknown effects, potentially increasing their susceptibiity to foodborne illnesses. Unlike physiology factors that mostly affect the host susceptibility, the exposure to foodborne pathogens are tied to human behaviour, specifically consumption, food handling, and preparation proceures. The combination of proper hygiene and sanitation related to food handling and preparation, appropriate methods of refrigeration and freezing, and thorough cooking of foods comprises a very effective aproach to preventing foodborne illness. An approach that should not be underestimated since food manufacturers cannot consistently provide foods guaranteed to be free of pathogens. In fact, as new issues emerge, some will be best addressed through the application of control technologies during food production and processing, but others may be best addressed at the consumer level through modification of exposure or susceptibility. Pathogenicity is the ability to casue illness. Some pathogens cause illness by infecting the human host, while others produce toxins that cause illness when consumed. Foodborne illness is caused then by viral, bacterial, or parasitic infections; toxins produced during microbial growth in food; and toxins produced by algal and fungal species. The infectious dose varies greatly depending on the pathogen. In some cases, it may take more than 100 millions cells of one pathogen to cause illness, while the infectious dose of an extrremelly virulent pathogen might be less than 10 cells. Some pathogenic microorganisms are significantly more virulent tant others. Virulence may vary within species, subspecies, and even different strains. Moreover, pathogens are living microorganisms that rapidly adapt and evolve. In fact, at optimal growth conditions a pathogen could evolve in a matter of hours. They do it in two ways, by mutation or by genetic exchange. Environmental forces may select a mutation that confers an advantage in the face of a particular adverse condition (such as acidity and temperature). Those adverse conditions are called environmental stress, and some we use to control pathogens proliferation. In addition, environmental stresses can create microorganisms with greatly enhanced mutation frequencies, increasing their adaptation opportunities. These new microorganisms also may more readily share genetic material with other remoted related species. Transfer of the genetic material encoding virulent factors may create rapidly a new pathogen from a previous unpathogenic microorganism. Like any use of antibiotics in medicine, the addition of antibiotics to animal feed or production agriculture has the potential to promote the development and dissemination of antibiotic-resitant microorganisms. In addition, antibiotics, like other environmetnal stresses, may accelerate the rate of microbial mutations. Pathogenic microorganisms can be introduced at any point in the food chain. Some pathogen contamination is the result of production agriculture conditions, because the farm environment has so many oportunities for contamination that complete control is impossible. Other times, contamination occurs from environmental sources during processing. Some pathogens are introduced during handling and food preparation, either through inadequate human sanitation or through cross-contamination by contact witho other foods. Pathogen control can be divided into three goals: prevent pathogen contamination, inactivate pathogens present in the food, and prevent or limit pathogen growth. Companies take numerous steps to prevent or minimize contamination of raw ingredients and unfinished product by using god manufacturing practices. The processing technologies used to inactivate pathogens vary by food product. Foods may be washed or rinsed with organic acids, sanitizers or other antimicrobial agents. Thermal processing heats a particular food to a specific temperature for a given time. Cooking and pasteuriztion are examples of this thermal processing. Non thermal processing technologies use other means to inactivate pathogens, such as pulsed electric fields, high pressure, or ultraviolet radiation. Other processing methods may change the characteristics of the food in a way to control pagthogens. For example, fermentation, drying and salting all change parameters of the food in a controlled manner to inhibit the pathogen growth. We cannot expect to solve the problem of microbiological food saftey to the point of havig a zero risk food supply. Even a food free of pathogens when it leaves the processing facility can become contaminated by the time it is consumed. Moreover, we want to consume safe food but we do not want to eat pills. Some foods cannot withstand rigorous processsing for safety and retain satisfactory sensory characteristics and sometimes nutritional profiles. Therefore, not all foods are made available in sterile conditions. The consumer demand for safe ‘fresher’ products is the driving force for alternative processing technologies that in spite of their potential will not be able to control all pathogens in all foods. |